Your jaw drops as she walks by,
but you never gave me a reply.
So now you can watch me wave my hand goodbye.

Do you want her?
Do you need me?
But you just aren't my cup of tea.
And you wish you knew her well.
And you wish you had me back.

I thought you were cool, the new boy in school.
When I saw you were headed my way.
Popcorn and movies, everything's groovy.
But you threw my lovin' away.

Do you want her?
Do you need me?
But you just aren't my cup of tea.
And you wish you knew her well.
And you wish you had me back.

Is she everything you wanted her to be?
Even though she isn't me?

Do you want her?
Do you need me?
But you just aren't my cup of tea.
And you wish you knew her well.
And you wish you had me back.